The Bell Witch: Killer or Friend? 

You can listen to the full podcast episode here, or watch the episode right here

After coexisting for over ten years, the Bell and Batts families were about to experience the chaotic presence of Kate. In 1817, the supernatural activity intensified as the Bells claimed to hear warnings from an unidentified voice. One message spoke of a disturbed spirit seeking a lost tooth, which aligned with the local belief that the Bell Farm and Bell Witch Cave were built on an ancient Native American burial site. Legend has it that a Bell child accidentally uncovered a human skull from the burial ground and brought it home, causing a tooth to slip through the floorboards and forever connecting the spirit to the house. Another instance involved the voice proclaiming itself as a spirit encompassing all realms and existing for millions of years.

Subsequently, the farm became a hotbed of paranormal phenomena. John Bell witnessed the apparition of a dog-like creature with a rabbit face, which vanished when he attempted to shoot it. Drewry Bell encountered an unusually large bird perched on a fence, while Betsy observed a girl swinging from an oak tree branch in a green dress. Dean, an enslaved person owned by the Bell family, reported being followed by a black dog during his visits to his wife in the evenings. Richard, the youngest son, diligently documented the haunting in his diary, describing knocking on doors and walls, gnawing on beds, invisible fighting dogs, and the sound of flapping wings on the ceiling. More disturbingly, choking and strangling sounds, along with dragging chains and heavy objects falling, permeated the house without any identifiable source. Despite thorough investigations, no rats were found, and furniture remained undamaged.

As time went on, the attacks from the witch intensified, particularly targeting Joel, Richard Williams, and Betsy. They endured physical violence, including hair pulling, pinching, and random strikes. Betsy, in particular, reported being pierced with pins, reminiscent of the pins that Kate had coerced from the town's women. Interestingly, the witch showed favoritism towards Lucy Bell, the mother, and John Junior, the son, leaving them relatively unharmed. In fact, the spirit praised Lucy as the epitome of perfection among women and displayed remarkable compassion towards her, even tending to her and singing during her illness. In contrast, John Junior engaged in intense conversations with the witch but harbored deep hostility, referring to her as the "Spirit of the Damned."

Meanwhile, John's health deteriorated rapidly. He suffered from sudden and severe illness, experiencing uncontrollable shaking, trembling, and choking sensations, as if something were lodged in his throat. At times, the symptoms escalated to the point of swelling or paralysis in his mouth.

Concerned for their beloved neighbors, the townsfolk attempted to intervene and appease the entity. They made multiple efforts to identify and pacify the witch, but she refused to cooperate. She consistently claimed to have been summoned by Kate Batts, the local witch, although Kate vehemently denied any involvement in the hauntings. Nevertheless, the witch seemed to respond to the name Kate and even identified herself as "Old Kate Batts' witch." This became the name by which everyone referred to her in subsequent communications.

To protect the family, William Porter, John Bell's son-in-law, tried to capture and kill the witch. He wrapped a shadowy figure in a blanket and attempted to throw it into the fire. However, according to his grandson, William Porter III, his efforts were in vain as the witch became inexplicably heavy the closer he got to the fire.

Word quickly spread about the haunting, attracting curious individuals from distant places who were eager to witness the witch firsthand. Eventually, the apparition began speaking audibly and, when questioned about its identity and motives, weakly declared, "I am a spirit; I was once very happy but have been disturbed." The spirit provided various explanations for its presence, attributing it to the disturbance of a Native American burial mound on the property. It even sent Drewry Bell and his friend Bennett Porter on a fruitless quest to find buried treasure.

Engaging in extensive conversations, the spirit demonstrated an uncanny ability to repeat two sermons delivered 13 miles apart simultaneously, displaying profound familiarity with biblical texts and relishing religious debates. As a source of entertainment, the witch would share gossip about activities occurring in other households and occasionally vanish momentarily, only to reappear after inquiries about her whereabouts. This mischievous side of the ghost, eager to spill the tea, resonates with my own curiosity.

In an attempt to test the witch's capabilities, a family friend's son, John Johnston, devised a question that only his family knew the answer to. He inquired about what his Dutch step-grandmother in North Carolina would say to the slaves if she believed they had done something wrong. Astonishingly, the witch responded in his grandmother's accent, saying, "Hut tut, what has happened now?"

On another occasion, an English visitor volunteered to investigate the situation. As he mentioned his family in England, the witch suddenly began mimicking the voices of his English parents. The next morning, the witch woke him up with the voices of his concerned parents, toying with his emotions.

Undoubtedly, the witch posed just as significant a problem for the town as Kate Batts did.

Let's return to the Bell family after a brief diversion. Despite the passing of time, they had to strive for a sense of normalcy. Some of the older boys pursued marriage and successful careers after completing college, while Betsy, being the youngest, remained at home. During this period, Betsy was courted by a man named Joshua Gardner, which inexplicably enraged the entity haunting the family. The entity's intentions became clear during an investigation when it expressed two goals: 1) to prevent Betsy from marrying the neighbor boy she was engaged to, and 2) to kill John.

Recognizing the seriousness of the situation, Betsy decided to break off her engagement with Joshua, believing that the witch was not to be trifled with. Unfortunately, it appears that the witch fulfilled its second threat. On December 20th, 1820, John was discovered lifeless in his bed, alongside an alleged bottle of black poison. As the family grappled with the shock of losing their patriarch, they heard the voice of the Bell Witch proclaim, "I gave ol' Jack a big dose of that last night, which fixed 'em."

Decades later, in 1894, Martin V. Ingram published a book titled "Authenticated History of the Bell Witch," which is widely regarded as the first comprehensive account of this legendary phenomenon and serves as a primary source for subsequent investigations. The book features real historical figures mentioned in relation to the events. While some modern skeptics have raised doubts about the authenticity of Ingram's work, deeming it either historical fiction or a fraudulent representation, it's important to note that differing opinions exist. For the purposes of this episode, we choose to embrace the belief in the Bell Witch's existence.

Naturally, as a devoted viewer of Ghost Adventures, I couldn't resist watching their episode dedicated to the Bell Witch. It turns out that Zak and his team were the first paranormal investigative show to gain access to the infamous Bell Witch Cave. The cave, believed to be the residence of the Bell Witch and situated on sacred burial grounds, provided compelling evidence to the Ghost Adventures crew, suggesting its significance as a sacred site and spiritual pathway for Indigenous communities. I have to admit, though, the episode was somewhat disappointing. If you're up for being underwhelmed by the Ghost Adventures crew once again, give it a watch.

It's worth mentioning that visitors to the cave, even in recent times, have reported encountering strange phenomena or falling seriously ill after removing rocks or pebbles from the natural cavern. The current owner of the property has regularly received packages containing rocks, accompanied by pleas to return them to the cave. These packages often include warnings recounting incidents where the sender, their family members, or friends suffered injuries or became severely ill.

In conclusion, what are your thoughts? Have you personally visited the cave and experienced any eerie encounters? While I haven't been there myself, I've heard that Tennessee has a reputation for being a uniquely spooky place. If you happen to reside in Tennessee, I'd love to hear from you and find out if it truly lives up to its creepy reputation.

Speaking personally, I fully embrace this story. As a firm believer in the supernatural and admittedly gullible, it's not much of a stretch for me to believe in this account.